On the other hand, everybody is allowed certain weaknesses. Mine happens to be cake. Not weakness in the sense that I can't resist eating a piece of cake, because I can (most of the time), but weakness in the sense that I cannot bake a cake to save my life. Cake is my achilles heel. This brings me to January 1, 2013: New Year's day. Also, coincidentally, my mother's birthday, and the conception of 'the cake of shame.'
The morning of New Year's day, my mother set off to run a few errands. As she turned the key in the ignition, she discovered the car to be unresponsive. The problem: dead battery. Frustratedly, my mother announced this discovery to my father, who is quite adept at fixing cars, and requested from me the temporary use of my car. I, of course, being the best daughter there is, relinquished my keys to my mother, and she went on her way. About twenty minutes later, our home phone rang. My dad answered it, made some frustrated grumbles, hung up, and immediately exited the house. I didn't think much of it at the time, until, that is, both of my parents returned home and informed me that my car too was now refusing to start (I know what you're thinking: What does this have to do with cake? Trust me, I'm getting there).
Now, with both cars being dead and my mother still having errands to run, my father found himself suddenly quite occupied. He called me downstairs and we had the following conversation (this is the abridged version; my memory ain't what it used to be):
Dad: So, your car is dead, and mom's car is dead...
Me: (suspiciously) Uh huh...?
Dad: I still have to make mom a birthday cake...
Me: (still suspicious) Uh huh...?
Dad: I can't do both.
Me: ...okay...
Dad: I'm going to need you to make the cake
Me: (thinking, "yeah, I can do this. Box mix all the way!") Oh, sure thing!
Dad: I need you to make an Italian sponge cake (there is no box mix for this, and it is probably the most disgustingly complicated cake ever involving the sifting of flour, grating of lemons, and whipping of eggs).
Me: (panicking slightly, knowing I suck at cake-making) Uh...okay...yeah, I mean, sure. No problem. Do we have a recipe for that?
Dad: We must someplace.
Me: Okey dokey, noooo problem (said with much more conviction and enthusiasm than I felt)
So, with that, I set off to find the recipe for Italian sponge cake. I should have mentioned before, my dad is pretty much a professional baker. He used to work in a restaurant in New Jersey, and he still works in a food-related industry. This being said, my dad does not often use recipes. I think that secretly, Italians aren't allowed to because it somehow means they fail at life. The recipes that he DOES have are written in restaurant-code. The measurements for everything are in pounds and handfulls, not cups and teaspoons. And there are no directions for how to proceed once you've gathered your ingredients. Realizing that I was not going to be able to follow my father's recipe, I looked to the internet for guidance.
I soon found a simple-looking recipe after searching for probably longer than I should have. I gathered my ingredients, and set off to work. Luckily, since the recipe was on my laptop, I had some handy-dandy entertainment while I baked. I would definitely need this, as the instructions informed me that I would need to beat 6 eggs with a hand-held electric mixer for 20 minutes straight, until they formed stiff peaks. Guys, I beg of you, never attempt to beat the egg yolks AND whites together if you want stiff peaks, It's not possible. Seriously. If you want peaks, get rid of the yolks. I did not know this, of course, so I proceeded to beat the crap out of those eggs for 30 whole minutes (Yes, the directions only said 20, but they obviously lied because I was not getting peaks) at the absolute highest setting, until I got very, very loose peaks, and I was almost positive my hand was about to break off. Even though the mixture only sort of doubled in size (as opposed to quadrupling, as the recipe stated it would) and did not, in fact, form any kind of peaks, I decided to go with it, because hey, what was the worst that could happen (plus, I could no longer feel my arm).
My father had told me to separate the batter into two 9-inch round pans, which, I don not feel should have been the case seeing as how there was barely enough batter to do this, but I forgot to compensate for the fact that I separated the batter when I set the oven timer. Consequently, the "cake" (I'm using quotes now because I cannot justifiably call this monstrosity a cake) spent a bit too much time in the oven. When I pulled it out, I knew it was looking a bit browner than it probably should have, but I thought it would be fine. After all, it smelled decent and looked at least a trifle edible. And if all else failed, we could just add a lot of frosting!
I was wrong.
When my mother got home, she found the cake of shame cooling on top of the oven. I explained to her my earlier mishaps, but expressed my beliefs that all would be well in the end. My mother, not believing me for a second, walked over to the oven and lifted the cakes out of their pans. Upon flipping them over, we saw that the bottoms of both cakes were completely black. Oh, and they were rock solid. Mmm, delish. I thought maybe the cakes could still be salvaged (I was desperate at this point), and suggested cutting off the bottoms (even though the cakes were each approximately one inch thick to begin with). My mom, calmly, but with laughter in her eyes, broke the news to me that their would be no saving these cakes. They would have to be baked over again. Guys, this was at least 4 hours of my life down the drain. Naturally, not wanting to admit total failure, I enthusiastically announced, "well, I bet they still taste good!" I cut off a small chunk of "cake," took a bite, and started chewing...and chewing...and chewing. Yet no matter how much I masticated, the cake was still there, not getting any weaker. Well, at least I had managed to make exactly what the directions said it would be: a sponge! Must have forgotten the cake part. My mom, amused by my endless chewing, decided to try it out herself. She took a bite and chewed...and chewed...and chewed...We both began laughing at this point. My mom asked, "does it ever go away?" I don't know the answer to this for sure, but my educated guess is no.
After determining the cake to be inedible, we found a new recipe, and I stood back and handed my mother ingredients as she prepared her own birthday cake. I watched with rapt attention as my mother tried to instruct me on how to properly prepare cake. I simply turned to her and said, "Mom, trust me, I am not going to attempt this ever again in my life. There's no point wasting your breath."
Later that afternoon, cake #2 (the edible one) was finished, and ready for decorating (which we both left for my father to complete). I walked over to "cake" #1 with one last hope that something could still be done, but at this point, it had cooled enough to erase any illusion that it would ever have been edible. You could pick the whole thing up with two fingers without it even bending in half or denting under the pressure of your fingertips. It was practically unbreakable as well, stretching only if puled forcefully apart at each end. Fortunately for my mother, cake #2 turned out well enough to actually be passable as a decent dessert (especially after my father layered it with fresh whipped cream and lemon curd), so all was not lost.
And guys, I have got to tell you, my dog and my brother's bird both LOVED my "cake."
("cake" #1 on the left, cake #2- the edible one, on the right)
~Felicia